Tag: DAO Governance

  • What are governance tokens and how do they work?

    What are governance tokens and how do they work?

    Many blockchain projects aim to operate without relying entirely on a central authority. Instead, they allow their communities to participate in certain decisions about how the project develops.

    But how can users take part in these decisions?

    One common approach is through governance tokens.

    Governance tokens give eligible holders the ability to participate in decision-making processes within a blockchain project or decentralised organisation. Depending on the project’s rules, holders may vote on protocol upgrades, treasury spending, fee changes, and other proposals.

    However, owning a governance token does not automatically mean you control a project or have unlimited decision-making power.

    In this lesson, we will explore what governance tokens are, how they work, their benefits, and the risks users should understand.

    1. What is a governance token?

    A governance token is a cryptocurrency token that provides holders with certain voting or decision-making rights within a blockchain project.

    Projects often use these tokens to involve their communities in governance.

    For example, imagine a decentralised lending platform wants to change its borrowing fees. Instead of allowing only its development team to make the decision, the project may submit a proposal for eligible token holders to vote on.

    Depending on the platform’s governance rules, holders can support or reject the proposal.

    Governance tokens are commonly associated with:

    • Decentralised finance (DeFi) protocols.
    • Decentralised autonomous organisations (DAOs).
    • Blockchain ecosystems.
    • Decentralised applications.
    • Community-managed treasuries.

    However, governance rights vary from one project to another. Some tokens offer voting rights over specific protocol decisions, while others provide broader participation in a DAO.

    2. How do governance tokens work?

    Governance tokens generally work through a proposal and voting process.

    Although the exact process differs between projects, it usually involves the following steps.

    Step 1: A proposal is created

    A community member, token holder, or authorised participant submits a proposal.

    For example, a DeFi protocol may receive a proposal to reduce borrowing fees or introduce support for another cryptocurrency.

    The proposal usually explains the suggested change and its possible impact.

    Step 2: The proposal is reviewed

    Before voting begins, the community may discuss the proposal.

    Members can examine its benefits, risks, technical requirements, and possible consequences.

    Some projects also require proposals to meet specific conditions before they become eligible for a formal vote.

    Step 3: Token holders vote

    Eligible governance token holders can cast votes according to the project’s rules.

    Depending on the governance model, voting power may depend on the number of tokens held, tokens delegated to a participant, or other eligibility requirements.

    For example, a project may use one token for one vote. In that model, a holder with 100 governance tokens has 100 votes.

    However, not every project follows this structure.

    Step 4: The proposal is approved or rejected

    After the voting period ends, the project checks whether the proposal meets the required approval conditions.

    These conditions may include:

    • Minimum participation requirements.
    • Required approval percentages.
    • Quorum thresholds.
    • Voting deadlines.

    If the proposal meets the conditions, it may move to implementation.

    Step 5: The approved change is implemented

    Some proposals execute automatically through smart contracts. Others require authorised contributors or developers to carry out the approved changes.

    Importantly, a successful vote does not always mean immediate implementation. The project may have additional execution steps, security reviews, or time delays.

    3. What decisions can governance token holders make?

    Governance tokens can allow communities to participate in different types of decisions.

    Here are some common examples.

    Protocol upgrades: Holders may vote on proposed changes to a blockchain application or protocol.

    Fee adjustments: A community may vote on changes to certain platform fees or fee distribution mechanisms.

    Treasury management: Eligible participants may vote on how a project’s community treasury should be used.

    New features: Governance proposals may introduce new products, services, or protocol functions.

    Risk parameters: DeFi projects may allow governance participants to vote on collateral requirements, borrowing limits, or other risk settings.

    Ecosystem development: Communities may vote on grants, partnerships, and funding for ecosystem projects.

    However, governance tokens do not necessarily give holders control over every part of a project. Some decisions may remain with developers, security teams, administrators, or other authorised groups.

    4. Examples of governance tokens

    Several well-known blockchain projects use governance tokens to support community participation.

    Here are a few examples:

    UNI – Uniswap

    <text color=”secondary” size=”xs”>Governance token of the Uniswap protocol</text>

    <AsyncImage query=”Uniswap UNI cryptocurrency token logo” aspectRatio=”16:9″ maxHeight={110} fit=”contain”/>

    UNI is associated with governance of the Uniswap protocol. Eligible participants can use UNI in governance processes concerning certain protocol decisions and ecosystem matters.

    AAVE – Aave

    <text color=”secondary” size=”xs”>Governance token of the Aave protocol</text>

    <AsyncImage query=”Aave AAVE cryptocurrency token logo” aspectRatio=”16:9″ maxHeight={110} fit=”contain”/>

    AAVE is used in the governance of the Aave ecosystem. Governance participants can vote on proposals affecting the protocol, subject to its governance rules.

    MKR – Maker ecosystem

    <text color=”secondary” size=”xs”>Governance token historically associated with MakerDAO</text>

    <AsyncImage query=”Maker MKR cryptocurrency token logo” aspectRatio=”16:9″ maxHeight={110} fit=”contain”/>

    MKR has historically played a governance role in the Maker ecosystem, which developed the Dai stablecoin system. The ecosystem has undergone governance and token changes, so users should check current official documentation when researching its present structure.

    These examples show that governance tokens can serve different purposes across blockchain ecosystems. Their voting rights and responsibilities are defined by each project’s rules.

    5. What are the benefits of governance tokens?

    Governance tokens can offer several benefits to decentralised projects and their communities.

    Community participation

    Governance tokens allow eligible holders to participate in decisions rather than leaving every decision to a central team.

    This can encourage community involvement and create a stronger connection between users and the project.

    Transparent decision-making

    Many blockchain governance systems publish proposals and voting results publicly.

    As a result, participants can review discussions, track decisions, and examine how governance processes work.

    Shared responsibility

    Governance systems can distribute certain decision-making responsibilities among multiple participants.

    This may reduce dependence on a single authority, depending on how the project is designed.

    Long-term ecosystem development

    Community members may contribute ideas, review proposals, and help decide how project resources should be used.

    This can support development and encourage participants to think about the project’s long-term direction.

    However, these benefits depend on meaningful participation, fair governance rules, and responsible decision-making.

    6. What are the risks of governance tokens?

    Although governance tokens provide voting opportunities, they also come with important risks.

    Voting power concentration

    In some projects, a small number of large token holders may control a significant share of voting power.

    This can make governance less representative of the wider community.

    For example, a few large holders may have enough voting power to influence or determine the outcome of a proposal.

    Low voter participation

    Not every token holder participates in governance.

    If only a small number of holders vote, decisions may reflect the preferences of a limited group rather than the wider community.

    Governance attacks

    An attacker may attempt to gain enough voting power to influence a proposal.

    Depending on the governance design, this could involve acquiring tokens, borrowing voting power, or exploiting weaknesses in the voting system.

    Some protocols use safeguards to reduce these risks, but no system is completely protected.

    Poor decision-making

    Token holders may not always have the technical knowledge required to evaluate complex proposals.

    As a result, decisions may create unintended consequences for the protocol.

    Token price volatility

    Governance tokens are cryptocurrencies, so their market prices can fluctuate.

    Their value may change because of market conditions, project developments, governance decisions, and investor sentiment.

    Smart contract vulnerabilities

    Some governance systems rely on smart contracts to manage proposals, voting, and execution.

    A vulnerability in these contracts could affect voting processes or the implementation of approved proposals.

    7. Governance tokens vs utility tokens

    Governance tokens and utility tokens serve different primary purposes, although a token can sometimes have both functions.

    Governance tokensUtility tokens
    Provide certain governance or voting rightsProvide access to products, services, or network functions
    Allow eligible holders to participate in decisionsMay be used for payments, fees, or application features
    Focus on decision-making participationFocus on practical use within an ecosystem
    Voting power depends on project rulesUsage depends on the token’s design

    For example, a governance token may allow holders to vote on protocol changes, while a utility token may be used to pay transaction fees.

    However, some projects combine governance and utility features in a single token.

    8. How can you research a governance token before investing?

    Before considering a governance token, understand what rights it actually provides.

    Use this checklist:

    1. Read the official documentation: Understand the token’s purpose and governance structure.
    2. Check voting rights: Find out which decisions token holders can influence.
    3. Review voting power: Understand whether voting depends on token balances, delegation, or another mechanism.
    4. Examine participation: Check whether community members actively participate in proposals.
    5. Study governance history: Review previous proposals and voting outcomes.
    6. Check decentralisation: Understand whether a small number of holders control most voting power.
    7. Review tokenomics: Examine supply, distribution, vesting, and unlock schedules.
    8. Understand implementation: Check who can execute approved proposals and whether additional permissions exist.

    Most importantly, do not assume that a governance token guarantees control over a project.

    A token’s voting rights may be limited, and some decisions may still depend on developers or authorised administrators.

    Final thoughts

    Governance tokens are an important part of many decentralised blockchain ecosystems. They allow eligible holders to participate in decisions about protocol changes, treasury management, fees, and other project matters.

    However, governance does not automatically mean complete decentralisation. Voting power concentration, low participation, technical vulnerabilities, and poor decision-making can affect how these systems operate.

    Before researching or investing in a governance token, understand what rights it provides, how voting works, and who controls the implementation process.

    Remember, owning a governance token is not the same as owning a share in a company or receiving guaranteed financial benefits.

    Frequently asked questions

    1. What is a governance token in simple words?

    A governance token is a cryptocurrency that gives eligible holders certain voting or decision-making rights within a blockchain project or decentralised organisation.

    2. Do governance tokens always provide voting rights?

    Not necessarily. The rights associated with a token depend on its design and the project’s governance rules. Always check the official documentation to understand what participation it allows.

    3. How is voting power calculated?

    Some projects use a one-token-one-vote model. Others use delegated voting, locked tokens, or different eligibility rules. Therefore, voting power can vary between governance systems.

    4. Can governance token holders control an entire blockchain project?

    Not always. Token holders may vote on specific decisions, but developers, administrators, security teams, and other authorised participants may retain certain responsibilities or permissions.

    5. Are governance tokens a good investment?

    There is no guaranteed answer. Their value depends on market demand, token supply, project development, governance participation, and other factors. Voting rights alone do not guarantee future returns.

    6. What is the difference between a governance token and a company share?

    A company share may represent ownership rights and claims defined by corporate law. A governance token generally provides specific participation rights within a blockchain project. It does not automatically provide company ownership, dividends, or legal shareholder rights.

    Disclaimer

    This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Governance tokens involve risks, including price volatility, concentrated voting power, governance attacks, smart contract vulnerabilities, and changes to project rules. Always conduct independent research and understand the rights and risks associated with a token before making any investment decision.

  • How do smart contract upgrades work and why do they matter?

    How do smart contract upgrades work and why do they matter?

    Smart contracts are an important part of blockchain technology. They power decentralised applications, token transfers, lending platforms, NFT marketplaces, and many other blockchain-based services.

    However, what happens when a smart contract contains a bug, needs a security improvement, or requires a new feature?

    Unlike traditional software, smart contracts often run on blockchains where deployed code cannot simply be edited like a regular application. Therefore, developers need specific methods to update or replace smart contracts.

    This process is known as a smart contract upgrade.

    In this lesson, we will explore how smart contract upgrades work, why projects need them, and what risks users should understand before interacting with upgradeable contracts.

    1. What is a smart contract?

    A smart contract is a programme deployed on a blockchain that executes instructions when predefined conditions are met.

    For example, imagine a decentralised lending application. A smart contract can manage deposits, calculate interest according to its programmed rules, and process eligible withdrawals.

    Once deployed, the contract operates according to its code and the rules of the blockchain.

    However, developers may discover problems or identify opportunities to improve the contract after deployment. In such cases, an upgrade may become necessary.

    2. What is a smart contract upgrade?

    A smart contract upgrade is a process used to change or improve the functionality of an existing blockchain application.

    An upgrade may introduce new features, fix vulnerabilities, improve performance, or modify existing rules.

    For example, suppose a decentralised application has a smart contract that supports token deposits and withdrawals. Later, developers identify a security weakness in its withdrawal process.

    They may introduce an updated contract that addresses the issue.

    However, the method used to upgrade a contract depends on how developers designed it before deployment.

    Importantly, not every smart contract can be upgraded directly. Some contracts are designed to remain unchanged after deployment.

    3. Why do smart contracts need upgrades?

    Although developers test smart contracts before deployment, no software is completely free from errors or vulnerabilities.

    Here are some common reasons why projects upgrade their contracts.

    Security improvements

    Security is one of the main reasons for contract upgrades.

    Developers may discover vulnerabilities that could allow unauthorised access, incorrect transactions, or loss of funds. Therefore, they may need to introduce changes to reduce these risks.

    However, an upgrade cannot guarantee complete security. The updated code must also undergo careful testing and review.

    Bug fixes

    Sometimes, a contract may contain programming errors that affect how it performs certain operations.

    For example, a calculation error could cause a reward distribution mechanism to work incorrectly.

    Developers may release an updated implementation to correct the issue.

    Adding new features

    Blockchain applications evolve over time. As a result, developers may introduce new features to improve the user experience or support additional services.

    For instance, a decentralised finance application may update its contract to support another token or introduce a new lending feature.

    Improving efficiency

    Developers may also upgrade contracts to improve how they use blockchain resources.

    For example, changes may reduce unnecessary operations or make certain processes more efficient. However, any proposed change must still follow the rules of the blockchain.

    Adapting to changing requirements

    A project may need to change its contract logic as its ecosystem grows.

    For example, developers may update governance rules, introduce new reward mechanisms, or modify certain parameters to support the application’s development.

    4. How do smart contract upgrades work?

    There are different ways to upgrade smart contracts. The approach depends on the contract’s original design.

    Let’s understand three common methods.

    Method 1: Deploying a new contract

    One straightforward method is to deploy a completely new smart contract.

    Developers create an updated version, test it, and deploy it to the blockchain.

    After deployment, the project may ask users to interact with the new contract instead of the old one.

    For example, a token project may deploy a new contract to introduce improved functionality. Depending on the design, users may need to transfer or migrate their tokens to the new contract.

    However, this method can create additional work for users and developers. The old contract may also remain on the blockchain, even after the project stops using it.

    Method 2: Proxy contracts

    A proxy contract is a common method for creating upgradeable smart contracts.

    In this arrangement, users interact with a proxy contract, which delegates execution to another contract called the implementation contract.

    The proxy generally maintains the relevant storage, while the implementation contract contains the logic used to execute operations.

    When developers upgrade the application, they can change which implementation the proxy points to.

    This allows the application to use updated logic while retaining the proxy address and, when correctly designed, its existing state.

    Although proxy contracts make upgrades easier, they introduce additional considerations. For example, incorrect storage layouts or poorly controlled upgrade permissions can create serious security problems.

    Method 3: Diamond pattern

    The Diamond pattern is another approach to building upgradeable smart contracts.

    Instead of relying on one large implementation contract, it divides functionality into smaller modules called facets.

    Each facet handles specific functions. A central diamond contract routes user requests to the relevant facet.

    Developers can add, replace, or remove certain facets without replacing the entire application structure.

    This approach can be useful for complex applications. However, it also introduces additional design and security considerations.

    5. Who controls smart contract upgrades?

    One important question is: who has permission to change a smart contract?

    The answer depends on the project’s governance and contract design.

    Some projects allow a development team or administrator to approve upgrades. Others use multisignature wallets, decentralised governance, or time-lock mechanisms.

    Here are some common arrangements:

    • Admin-controlled upgrades: A designated administrator can approve or execute contract changes.
    • Multisignature approval: Multiple authorised signers must approve an upgrade before it can proceed.
    • DAO governance: Token holders or designated governance participants vote on proposed changes, according to the project’s rules.
    • Timelock mechanism: An approved upgrade must wait for a specified period before execution.

    These arrangements can improve accountability, but they do not automatically make a contract safe.

    For example, if one administrator has unrestricted upgrade permissions, that person or compromised account may be able to change the contract’s behaviour.

    Therefore, always check who controls the upgrade mechanism.

    6. What are the risks of smart contract upgrades?

    Upgradeable contracts offer flexibility, but they also introduce risks that users should understand.

    Centralisation risk

    If only one person or organisation controls upgrades, users must trust that authority to act responsibly.

    A compromised administrator account could potentially approve harmful changes.

    Malicious upgrades

    An authorised upgrade mechanism could be misused to introduce harmful code.

    Depending on the contract’s permissions and design, this could affect user balances, withdrawals, or other application functions.

    Storage compatibility problems

    Upgradeable contracts must handle stored data carefully.

    For example, a poorly designed implementation update may change how the contract reads or writes existing data. This can lead to unexpected behaviour or application failures.

    New vulnerabilities

    An upgrade intended to improve security may introduce new bugs.

    Therefore, developers should test updated code and arrange appropriate security reviews before implementation.

    Governance risks

    If upgrades depend on community voting, low participation or concentrated voting power may affect decisions.

    As a result, governance processes should be transparent and clearly documented.

    User confusion

    Some upgrades require users to migrate tokens, approve new contracts, or take other actions.

    Without clear communication, users may interact with outdated contracts or fall victim to fake upgrade announcements.

    Always verify upgrade instructions through official project channels.

    7. How can users check whether a smart contract is upgradeable?

    You do not need to be a blockchain developer to perform basic checks.

    However, you should know where to look.

    Here are some useful steps:

    1. Check the contract address: Find the official address through the project’s verified website or documentation.
    2. Use a blockchain explorer: Open the contract on an explorer such as Etherscan.
    3. Review the contract information: Look for verified source code and proxy indicators, where available.
    4. Check upgrade permissions: Examine whether an administrator, multisignature wallet, or governance mechanism controls upgrades.
    5. Review upgrade history: Check whether the implementation address or contract logic has changed.
    6. Read official announcements: Verify whether the project has explained the reason and impact of an upgrade.

    A blockchain explorer can help you inspect contract activity and verified code. However, interpreting proxy permissions and implementation details may require technical knowledge.

    8. Upgradeable vs immutable smart contracts

    Not every project chooses to make its smart contracts upgradeable.

    Some contracts are designed to remain immutable, meaning their deployed code cannot be changed through an administrative upgrade mechanism.

    Upgradeable contractsImmutable contracts
    Can support changes through an upgrade mechanismDeployed code cannot be directly changed
    Allow developers to fix bugs or add features through upgradesChanges generally require deploying a new contract
    May depend on administrators or governanceAvoid certain upgrade-control risks
    Require users to consider upgrade permissionsStill carry risks from original code and design

    Neither approach is automatically better in every situation.

    Upgradeable contracts offer flexibility, while immutable contracts provide stronger guarantees that their deployed logic will not be changed through an upgrade mechanism.

    However, immutability does not guarantee that a contract is secure or free from bugs.

    Final thoughts

    Smart contract upgrades help blockchain applications adapt, improve security, fix bugs, and introduce new features.

    At the same time, they create important questions about permissions, governance, storage compatibility, and user protection.

    Before interacting with an upgradeable contract, understand who controls it, how upgrades are approved, and whether the project communicates changes transparently.

    Most importantly, remember that an upgradeable contract is not automatically unsafe, and an immutable contract is not automatically secure. The quality of the code, security practices, and governance structure all matter.

    Frequently asked questions

    1. Can smart contracts be changed after deployment?

    Some smart contracts can be upgraded through mechanisms such as proxy contracts. However, contracts without an upgrade mechanism generally cannot have their deployed code directly modified.

    2. What is a proxy contract in blockchain?

    A proxy contract is a contract that allows users to interact with an application while delegating execution to a separate implementation contract. Developers can update the implementation without necessarily changing the proxy address.

    3. Are upgradeable smart contracts safe?

    Upgradeable contracts can be useful, but their safety depends on code quality, testing, upgrade permissions, governance, and security practices. Poorly controlled upgrade mechanisms can create additional risks.

    4. What is an immutable smart contract?

    An immutable smart contract is designed so that its deployed code cannot be directly changed through an upgrade mechanism. If developers need different functionality, they generally deploy another contract.

    5. Who can approve a smart contract upgrade?

    Depending on the design, upgrades may be controlled by an administrator, a multisignature wallet, a DAO governance process, or another authorised mechanism.

    6. Does a smart contract audit guarantee that an upgrade is safe?

    No. An audit reviews code within a defined scope, but it cannot guarantee complete security. Updated implementations should also undergo appropriate testing and security reviews.

    Disclaimer

    This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, investment, legal, or technical advice. Smart contract upgrades involve potential security, governance, and operational risks. Always verify contract addresses, review official documentation, and conduct independent research before interacting with blockchain applications.